Friday, May 8, 2009

Piano Recital

The girls had a piano recital last night - Kara's first. They both had their songs memorized and did fabulous.

I would like to take a moment, though, and say how much I miss our previous piano teacher:

* She charged less and did so much more.
* Incorporated primary songs into the lesson plan.
* Had fun, well-known songs to choose from for the kids to learn, especially for recitals. It makes a difference when the child is a little more excited to play a song others can recognize.
* Had the kids learn something just a little harder than they thought they could do for recital so they would have something to be so much prouder of. Current one gives them something a little below their skills to ensure success.
* Teaches the kids to introduce themselves, the song, and the composer at recitals. Current teacher believes it is hard enough playing the piece, she wants to make it as easy for them as possible.
* She had a gift for every student, not just two who have excelled the most.

I can understand the point of view of the current piano teacher. But, it makes me feel that she has no confidence in her students and their abilities. I think it is important that if a person is going to learn to play in front of others, they should learn ALL of the skills that involves, including the introduction. I have come to recognize that no other will live up to the excellence of our first piano teacher. Kudos to you, Mikki.

I was so proud of the girls. They both did well and made no mistakes. Apparently, this was not a great first experience for Kara, though. She was practically in tears because she was the only one who "did not play with two hands at the same time." If she had been given a song at or above her ability level, that would not have been an issue. It was also very disappointing to leave without any kind of gift/reward/recognition for their efforts during the year. So, off we went to the local ice cream stand!!!

1 comment:

Mathie Fam said...

Two different philosophies of teaching. I totally agree with you on this one. If you haven't, I would definitely voice your concerns with the teacher. Teaching myself i always appreciated when I got some feedback, whether positive or negative.

I am going to start taking more students once we move and get settled if you're interested. I am not sure when that will actually be, but the offer is there.